Willpower Is For Fat People

Because getting in shape shouldn't suck

  • Home
  • Blog
    • Polls Archive
  • Undieting
    • You are not me
    • How to lie with science
    • Are you steam powered?
    • Eating is not a sport
    • You are NOT what you eat
    • Eat consciously — except when you don’t
    • Diets don’t burn fat, they burn money
  • About
    • About Me
  • Contact
  • Daily Weigh-in
  • Forum

Powered by Genesis

Too much protein in middle age ‘as bad as smoking’

By Drew

Steak over charcoal

Photo by WmJR

OMG if I eat steak I’m gonna DIE!

Or, like something like that. I guess. According to Medical News Today.

Two new studies conclude that low protein intake may hold the key to a long and healthy life, at least until old age.

How’s that? Low protein is good for a long life, until I’m actually old. Can you explain that?

Another key finding is the suggestion that while a high-protein diet may in the short term help people lose weight and body fat, in the long term it may harm health and reduce lifespan.

So eating lots of protein will help me lose weight and body fat, which everyone is telling me I should do. But if I keep eating that way it will kill me when I get old?

He and his colleagues showed that high protein consumption is linked to increased risk of cancer, diabetes and death in middle-aged adults, although this was not the case for older adults who may benefit from moderate protein consumption.

Well now they’re not even getting their story straight.

The summary

The study they’re reporting on actually showed that a high-protein diet was “bad” for you from age 50-65, after which it was “good” for you. Which is a brain-bender already, but then they get the good/bad backwards the first two times they mention it, and lead with a headline that only mentions half the conclusion anyway.

Click here for a fuller analysis of what’s wrong with this study.

Study referenced

Share this:

  • Share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • More
  • Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Recent Posts

  • Willpower is your goalie
  • I know, let’s blame your parents!
  • You can’t “add healthy” to junk
  • Don’t you just love how horrible this is?
  • Anybody want a cookie?

Recent Comments

  • Drew on I know, let’s blame your parents!
  • Murphy Kismet on I know, let’s blame your parents!
  • Drew on Anybody want a cookie?
  • June on Anybody want a cookie?
  • AHA wants you to kill yourself - Willpower Is For Fat People on What is that supposed to mean?